|
Home > Archive > Data Storage > October 2007 > Backup SW /w Encryption and Remote Storage
You are viewing an archived Text-only version of the thread.
To view this thread in it's original format and/or if you want to reply to
this thread please [click here]
| Author |
Backup SW /w Encryption and Remote Storage
|
|
| hufaunder@yahoo.com 2007-09-04, 1:14 am |
| I want to backup my data in a remote location. The total size of the
data is about 500GB but the incremental data is comparably small. A
commercial online backup service is one option but I much prefer a
backup on a family's computer on a different continent. In any case,
here are the requirements:
1) Data must be strongly encrypted before sending it over the wire.
2) When a connection breaks the backup process has to pick up where it
stopped, i.e. without data corruption or having to resend the data.
3) Incremental backup is a MUST.
4) It must be possible to automatically backup data from different
locations within an internal network.
5) The solution should be inexpensive (<$200).
Is there anything out there that can handle this? Any input is
appreciated.
| |
| M.I.5¾ 2007-09-04, 7:14 am |
|
<hufaunder@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:1188881992.382374.216310@d55g2000hsg.googlegroups.com...
>I want to backup my data in a remote location. The total size of the
> data is about 500GB but the incremental data is comparably small. A
> commercial online backup service is one option but I much prefer a
> backup on a family's computer on a different continent. In any case,
> here are the requirements:
>
Backing up in a location off site from the machine being backed up is a
sound principle. But isn't backing up to a different continent going just a
bit too far? Where were you proposing to put you second backup*, the moon?
Seriously though, with the price of hard disk drives these days being so
cheap, why not backup to a pair of hard disk drives and just store them in
another building when not actually being backed up to. If your that worried
about security of the data, stick 'em in a fire safe. The more complicated
you make your backup regime, the more likely you are to be disappointed when
you come to restore it under circumstances that you can't make another.
*A backup is not a backup unless it's backed up.
| |
| hufaunder@yahoo.com 2007-09-04, 1:14 pm |
| On Sep 4, 1:59 am, "M.I.5=BE" <no....@no.where.NO_SPAM.co.uk> wrote:
> <hufaun...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
>
> news:1188881992.382374.216310@d55g2000hsg.googlegroups.com...
>
>
> Backing up in a location off site from the machine being backed up is a
> sound principle. But isn't backing up to a different continent going jus=
t a
> bit too far? Where were you proposing to put you second backup*, the moo=
n?
>
> Seriously though, with the price of hard disk drives these days being so
> cheap, why not backup to a pair of hard disk drives and just store them in
> another building when not actually being backed up to. If your that worr=
ied
> about security of the data, stick 'em in a fire safe. The more complicat=
ed
> you make your backup regime, the more likely you are to be disappointed w=
hen
> you come to restore it under circumstances that you can't make another.
>
> *A backup is not a backup unless it's backed up.
Hm, none of this is actually answering any of my questions. As for the
location of the backup what does it matter if I store the backup at an
online service next town or on a different continent? I have good
reason for the location mentioned that go beyond security. As for
storing it on another HD and leave that at work or a safe it's a major
hassle. I want the backup process to be automated and not having to
carry a HD around for doing backups.
Any input on the original question?
| |
| John Wunderlich 2007-09-04, 7:14 pm |
| "hufaunder@yahoo.com" <hufaunder@yahoo.com> wrote in
news:1188881992.382374.216310@d55g2000hsg.googlegroups.com:
> I want to backup my data in a remote location. The total size of
> the data is about 500GB but the incremental data is comparably
> small. A commercial online backup service is one option but I much
> prefer a backup on a family's computer on a different continent.
> In any case, here are the requirements:
>
> 1) Data must be strongly encrypted before sending it over the
> wire. 2) When a connection breaks the backup process has to pick
> up where it stopped, i.e. without data corruption or having to
> resend the data. 3) Incremental backup is a MUST.
> 4) It must be possible to automatically backup data from different
> locations within an internal network.
> 5) The solution should be inexpensive (<$200).
>
> Is there anything out there that can handle this? Any input is
> appreciated.
>
Assuming you connect to your remote server using a VPN connection, and
can connect to the backup medium using Windows Networking (NetBT), then
to handle the strong security/encryption part, try Freeware Truecrypt
<http://www.truecrypt.org>
As for the Backup program, you might want to try the built-in Windows
Backup program. I'm not sure how it fares with your requirements,
though...
Start->Programs->Accessories->System Tools->Backup.
It doesn't get much cheaper.
-- John
| |
| norman_news@yahoo.com 2007-09-07, 7:16 pm |
| On Sep 4, 4:59 am, "M.I.5=BE" <no....@no.where.NO_SPAM.co.uk> wrote:
> <hufaun...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
> If your that worried
> about security of the data, stick 'em in a fire safe.
Be careful about that. A typical document safe is designed to keep
paper from burning, which happens at either 300 or 500 degrees
(Celsius I think....memory isn't working right now). Either way, I
don't believe a CD or HD would survive such temperatures.
| |
| norman_news@yahoo.com 2007-09-07, 7:16 pm |
| hufaunder@yahoo.com wrote:
> I want to backup my data in a remote location. The total size of the
> data is about 500GB but the incremental data is comparably small. A
Your ISP may not appreciate you sending 500G a few times a month. Even
unlimited accounts have limits.
> 1) Data must be strongly encrypted before sending it over the wire.
> 2) When a connection breaks the backup process has to pick up where it
> stopped, i.e. without data corruption or having to resend the data.
> 3) Incremental backup is a MUST.
> 4) It must be possible to automatically backup data from different
> locations within an internal network.
> 5) The solution should be inexpensive (<$200).
I'm using PGP 6.5.8 (freeware), and have had some success using it on
a LAN. I wonder if it would work over the internet. It should be
secure enough that you could use pretty much anything to do your
transfer.
| |
| M.I.5¾ 2007-09-10, 7:11 am |
|
<norman_news@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:1189191620.346678.161180@19g2000hsx.googlegroups.com...
On Sep 4, 4:59 am, "M.I.5¾" <no....@no.where.NO_SPAM.co.uk> wrote:
> <hufaun...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
> If your that worried
> about security of the data, stick 'em in a fire safe.
Be careful about that. A typical document safe is designed to keep
paper from burning, which happens at either 300 or 500 degrees
(Celsius I think....memory isn't working right now). Either way, I
don't believe a CD or HD would survive such temperatures.
-----------------
I was thinking more along the lines of physical security. Fire safes are
gererally adequate to the task and generally available at quite reasonable
prices.
| |
| Rick Thomas 2007-10-23, 7:15 am |
| Have you looked at rsync?
It can transport over ssh encrypted channels and moves only the changed
data. It's optimized for slow (as in WAN) links.
hufaunder@yahoo.com wrote:
> I want to backup my data in a remote location. The total size of the
> data is about 500GB but the incremental data is comparably small. A
> commercial online backup service is one option but I much prefer a
> backup on a family's computer on a different continent. In any case,
> here are the requirements:
>
> 1) Data must be strongly encrypted before sending it over the wire.
> 2) When a connection breaks the backup process has to pick up where it
> stopped, i.e. without data corruption or having to resend the data.
> 3) Incremental backup is a MUST.
> 4) It must be possible to automatically backup data from different
> locations within an internal network.
> 5) The solution should be inexpensive (<$200).
>
> Is there anything out there that can handle this? Any input is
> appreciated.
>
|
|
|
|
|