I've got several (old) routers; EA 130, ASR-8100, SAR715PV but none of them
seem able to support Voip without a proxy. I tried setting the DMZ to my
ATA's address but no joy, I guess I need to set the individual ports but
it's apparently not possible on any of these router. Seeing that I've
already got the ATU's I don't want a combined VOIP router. Anyone recommend
a good (cheap) router that well support VOIP properly ?

Thanks
Greg

[ Post a follow-up to this message ]

"Greg" <Greg@otbm.com> wrote in message
news:g6WdnSA359RrA43eRVnysA@pipex.net
> I've got several (old) routers; EA 130, ASR-8100,
> SAR715PV but none of them seem able to support Voip
> without a proxy. I tried setting the DMZ to my ATA's
> address but no joy, I guess I need to set the individual
> ports but it's apparently not possible on any of these
> router. Seeing that I've already got the ATU's I don't
> want a combined VOIP router. Anyone recommend a good
> (cheap) router that well support VOIP properly ?
> Thanks
> Greg

What VoIP provider..? What ATA..? Are you using STUN..?

Some more info would be helpful..! I must admit I've never come across an
ATA that wouldn't function with its IP address in the router's DMZ, that
is an odd one.

Ivor

[ Post a follow-up to this message ]

>
> What VoIP provider..? What ATA..? Are you using STUN..?
>
> Some more info would be helpful..! I must admit I've never come across an
> ATA that wouldn't function with its IP address in the router's DMZ, that
> is an odd one.
>

I've tried a few combinations but for example: ATA - SPA 3000, provider
1899, router ASR 8100 with DMZ set to ATA. It registers ok, I can ring out
ok, but only one-way voice ! That is: I can hear them but they cant hear me.

thanks

Greg

[ Post a follow-up to this message ]

Greg wrote:
> I've got several (old) routers; EA 130, ASR-8100, SAR715PV but none of the
m
> seem able to support Voip without a proxy. I tried setting the DMZ to my
> ATA's address but no joy, I guess I need to set the individual ports but
> it's apparently not possible on any of these router. Seeing that I've
> already got the ATU's I don't want a combined VOIP router. Anyone recommen
d
> a good (cheap) router that well support VOIP properly ?
>
> Thanks
> Greg
>
>

I have used the ASR-8100 for VOIP.  You will need port forwarding, they
call it 'Virtual Server'.

[ Post a follow-up to this message ]

"Greg" <Greg@otbm.com> wrote in message
 news:qtGdnZ2dnZ3X0zbEnZ2dnTQhjd6dnZ2dRVn
yq52dnZ0@pipex.net 
>
> I've tried a few combinations but for example: ATA - SPA
> 3000, provider 1899, router ASR 8100 with DMZ set to ATA.
> It registers ok, I can ring out ok, but only one-way
> voice ! That is: I can hear them but they cant hear me.

One way audio is typical of the ports not being forwarded correctly. I
don't know about 1899 so can't comment on it specifically, but does it use
STUN..? Sometimes setting the ATA to use STUN and not forwarding any
specific ports can work, but to be honest it can sometimes be a hit and
miss affair, as you've found out..!

Ivor

[ Post a follow-up to this message ]

>
> I have used the ASR-8100 for VOIP.  You will need port forwarding, they
> call it 'Virtual Server'.

Yes tried 'virtual server' but didn't seem to do the trick :-(  do you
remember which port's you opened ?

greg

[ Post a follow-up to this message ]

Greg wrote: 
>
>
> Yes tried 'virtual server' but didn't seem to do the trick :-(  do you
> remember which port's you opened ?
>
> greg
>
>

It may well be an overkill, but it worked:

1 	5060 	5060 	5060 	TCP 	10.0.0.x
2 	5060 	5060 	5060 	UDP 	10.0.0.x
3 	5004 	5004 	5004 	UDP 	10.0.0.x
4 	10000 	10000 	10000 	UDP 	10.0.0.x
5 	16348 	16348 	16348 	UDP 	10.0.0.x

[ Post a follow-up to this message ]

 
>
> It may well be an overkill, but it worked:
>
> 1 5060 5060 5060 TCP 10.0.0.x 2 5060 5060 5060 UDP 10.0.0.x 3 5004 5004
> 5004 UDP 10.0.0.x 4 10000 10000 10000 UDP 10.0.0.x 5 16348 16348 16348 UDP
> 10.0.0.x


Thanks for that Dave, just tried it but still only one-way audio :-(
It's the exactly same if I try using Xlight. Really do think I need a newer
router. Thanks again.

greg

[ Post a follow-up to this message ]

"Greg" <Greg@otbm.com> wrote in message
news:g6WdnSA359RrA43eRVnysA@pipex.net...
> I've got several (old) routers; EA 130, ASR-8100, SAR715PV but none of
them
> seem able to support Voip without a proxy. I tried setting the DMZ to my
> ATA's address but no joy, I guess I need to set the individual ports but
> it's apparently not possible on any of these router. Seeing that I've
> already got the ATU's I don't want a combined VOIP router. Anyone
recommend
> a good (cheap) router that well support VOIP properly ?

Hi Greg
I have the 715pv and Yes it happily  works with SIP, and IAX. No problem at
all

You need to set up the port forwarding. This can be done manually or via the
very good application that can be downloaded that automates the process.

I have found the 715 very solid and to date hasnt locked up or needed
rebooting.

email me if you wat more info

Ian

[ Post a follow-up to this message ]

Greg wrote:
>
> Thanks for that Dave, just tried it but still only one-way audio :-(
> It's the exactly same if I try using Xlight. Really do think I need a newe
r
> router. Thanks again.

Hi Greg,

I've just tried the ASR-8100 with the settings i previously posted.  The
ports were forwarded to my Asterisk Server and it worked.  The
asterisk was not part of the DMZ.

Just to clarify, the previous settings - did you forward the ports to
the machine required.  ie, if you use X-lite to connect directly to VOIP
supplier - that IP etc.

Once the settings have been made, reboot the router for settings to take
effect.

As Ivan previous pointed out, this does seem like a typical port
forwarding issue.  Feel free to get a new router, but you'll porbably
find a similar issue.

[ Post a follow-up to this message ]